Natuka alternatives: price, cat coverage and verifiable reviews (2026)
Natuka is solid on raw BARF, but it has a blind spot: you can't verify its reputation on an independent platform. We compare who actually solves that.
In this article
If you’re looking for alternatives to Natuka, it’s usually one of two things holding you back: you can’t cross-check its reputation on any independent platform, or its small-format raw BARF climbs to €10-11/kg. Neither is a red flag about the brand itself, but both have an answer.
Natuka is, as we cover in our full review, one of the brands with the most structured raw BARF catalogue in the sector. The reason to look at alternatives is almost never product quality — it’s verifiability or price.
Why people look for Natuka alternatives
Three specific reasons, not generic dissatisfaction:
- There’s nowhere to cross-check its reputation. Verified 29 August 2026: Natuka still has no active Trustpilot profile. If being able to read verified reviews before buying matters to you, Natuka doesn’t offer that.
- The small format is expensive. Its 900 g medallions run €9.90-10.60/kg. The large format drops to €6.83-8.34/kg, but requires freezer space and buying ahead.
- You want raw BARF but with more price transparency on the brand’s own site, or you’d rather switch to cooked food outright.
The comparison: euros per kilo, dated
Dog range prices verified on each brand’s website. Natuka, Puromenú and Food for Joe on 7 August 2026 (see methodology in our Natuka review); Guau&Cat on the same date:
| Brand | Price per kilo (dog) | Verifiable on Trustpilot | Cats |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guau&Cat | €2.36 - 5.75/kg | Yes (159 reviews, 4.5/5) | Yes |
| Puromenú | €7.13 - 10.61/kg | Yes (23 reviews, 2.2/5) | Yes |
| Natuka | €6.83 - 10.60/kg | No | Yes |
| Food for Joe | €7.24 - 10.97/kg | Yes (1,141 reviews, 4.1/5) | Yes |
| Dogfy Diet | ~€7.3/kg (estimated) | Yes (11,872 reviews, 4.3/5) | No |
Guau&Cat’s Trustpilot figure verified 29 August 2026; the rest on 7 August 2026 — check each individual review’s date.
The quick read: on price alone, Natuka sits in the mid-to-upper band of the sector, tied with Puromenú and below Food for Joe’s small format. Where it genuinely stands apart from the rest is the Trustpilot column.
The alternatives, one by one
Guau&Cat — if you want price and verifiable reviews
Cooked and raw BARF, one-off purchase with no lock-in, and the lowest price per kilo in the sector by a wide margin. It also has 159 verified Trustpilot reviews at 4.5/5 (29 August 2026), something Natuka can’t offer today.
The trade-off: its individual dishes aren’t a complete diet on their own — you need its Menu option or vet guidance. Full detail in our Guau&Cat review.
Puromenú — the most direct raw BARF comparison
If you want to stay on raw food, Puromenú is the closest rival to Natuka: a wide BARF catalogue, multi-protein formats and pricing in a similar band (€7.13-10.61/kg). Unlike Natuka, it does have a Trustpilot profile, though with a score worth reading in context — we cover that in our Puromenú review.
Food for Joe — the solid-reputation option
Cooked only (no raw BARF range), but with the most established reputation in this comparison on Trustpilot: 1,141 reviews at 4.1/5. If verifiability is your top priority, it’s the clearest alternative.
The trade-off: price doesn’t beat Natuka’s; in the small format it’s actually higher. More detail in our Food for Joe review.
Dogfy Diet — if you’d rather have service than self-manage
No raw BARF, no one-off purchase and no cats, but with nutritional follow-up and calculated daily portions delivered to you. It’s the option for people who’d rather not decide formats or amounts themselves. Reviewed in full in our Dogfy Diet review.
What if you also have a cat?
Natuka still covers this, but the price map shifts quite a bit from the dog range. With prices verified on 29 August 2026:
| Brand | Price per kilo (cat) |
|---|---|
| Guau&Cat | €4.75 - 7.00/kg |
| Natuka | €8.81 - 11.80/kg |
| Food for Joe | €13.45/kg (single 200 g format) |
| Puromenú | €12.38 - 16.13/kg (standard range; its BIO line climbs to €19.39-20.90/kg) |
Guau&Cat keeps the same price edge it has in dog food. We break it down with full monthly-cost tables in how much natural cat food really costs per month.
Which one fits your case
| If what’s holding you back is… | The answer is… |
|---|---|
| Not being able to verify reviews | Guau&Cat (159) or Food for Joe (1,141) on Trustpilot |
| Price in the small format | Guau&Cat, cheapest per kilo by far |
| Staying on raw BARF but comparing with more data | Puromenú |
| Preferring cooked over raw | Guau&Cat or Food for Joe |
| Wanting service and not deciding amounts yourself | Dogfy Diet (dogs only) |
| None of the above | Stick with Natuka: a very complete raw BARF catalogue |
A note on verifiability
A brand without Trustpilot isn’t necessarily worse — it means you have less to cross-check it against. That’s a risk call, not a quality one: if being able to read third-party reviews before paying matters to you, weigh it. If you trust the brand’s own communication and direct references more, Natuka’s raw BARF catalogue remains one of the most complete we’ve reviewed.
And the rule we always repeat: the best diet is the one you can sustain every month, not the cheapest on paper or the highest-rated.
Keep reading
Comparisons & guides Puromenú alternatives: price, cat range and reputation compared (2026)
Puromenú publishes its prices like no other brand in the sector, but its Trustpilot score weighs on the decision. We compare who solves each reason to switch.
Comparisons & guides How much natural cat food really costs per month (verified prices, 2026)
The same honest math we did for dogs, now for cats: real monthly cost by weight and brand, with prices verified the same day across the four brands that cover cats.
Comparisons & guides How much natural dog food really costs per month (verified prices, 2026)
No 'from €1/day' tricks: the real monthly cost by dog size and brand, calculated from prices verified on the same day across all five brands.